Evans Family History, by Barry O’ Sullivan

OSullivan__Headstones_InchagoillThree O’ Sullivan headstones on Inchagoill, Sarah O’ Sullivan, nee Joyce


Who was Elisabeth Evans?

When I was a young boy my father would bring my brothers and I to Inchagoill on Lough Corrib, each year in early August, to attend mass and pray that we would not drown during the following year. This was probably wise as we were wild young lads, living within 100 metres of the lake, with access to boats at a time when lifejackets were unknown. On one of these pilgrimages I noticed three headstones in the graveyard with the name O’Sullivan. One in particular, the middle one, attracted my attention. Sarah O’Sullivan died in 1884, aged 37. I asked my father who she was.

He said she was his grandmother, Sarah Joyce, and she had died giving birth to his father, Bernard, and his twin brother, John. On her death, Sarah’s husband, also Bernard, was left with their 9 remaining children; the oldest Michael was 15. Bernard was farming 26 acres, half of which was bog, yet he erected a headstone to commemorate his wife at a time when headstones were rare. She was obviously special and although I was curious, my father could tell me no more about her.

Many years later, when the genealogy bug struck me, I found a marriage registration in Galway for Bernard Sullivan and Sarah Joyce. They married in Kilmilkin church, in the Maam valley, in 1866. Sarah’s father was Tobias Joyce of Culliagh, near Leenane. Tobias turned out to be the second son of Big Jack Joyce, “King of the Joyces”, and one-time proprietor of what is now the Leenane Hotel. He had often been written about by the travel writers in the 1830s.

Young Tobias (Toby) Joyce was mentioned in Henry Inglis’ traveller’s tale, written in 1834, as having a liaison with the beautiful Ms. Flynn of the Halfway House, near Maam Cross. But “the Joyces and Flynns not being entirely as one”, and Toby ended up marrying Elizabeth (Eliza) Evans in Clifden Church on 8th March 1840. Toby and Eliza were my great great grandparents.

In addition to my great grandmother Sarah, Toby and Eliza had ten other children. Patrick, the eldest, married his cousin Mary Joyce and settled in Leagaun. They had four children before Patrick died at a young age. Mary later married Martin Acton.

Another son, James B., became a butcher and farmer in Clifden. He later gained some notoriety when he bought Clifden Demesne in 1913 and was denounced from the pulpit by Canon McAlpine as a land grabber.

A daughter, Elizabeth, married John Joyce of Ungwee, Moyard, and their daughter Maggie “Ungee” had a shop in Clifden for many years. Maggie “Ungee” and her first cousin Maggie “Dick” (daughter of the aforementioned James B. and married to Dick Joyce) were regular visitors to their O’Sullivan cousins on the Doorus peninsula in Cornamona.

Elizabeth Evans daughter of Thomas Evans of Cleggan?

But now to my original question, who was my great great grandmother, Elizabeth Evans. Who were her father and mother? Had she brothers and sisters? What did her father do for a living? I think I may know some of the answers but I am not sure.

I think Elizabeth was the daughter of a Thomas Evans of Cleggan. Thomas was seneschal (a sort of small claims court judge) for the Manor of Claremount, of the Martins of Ballinahinch. He died in 1840 as there is an article mentioning his replacement in The Connaught Journal. He is buried in Ballinakill graveyard where, according to Ian Cantwells memorials of the dead, there is an inscription which includes his wife Margaret nee Toole. The inscription states that he was from Cashel, Co. Tipperary, where incidentally Humanity Dicks second wife Harriet Evans came from. I have failed to find this memorial when I visited Ballinakill but a number of memorials lying close to the old church are almost impossible to decipher.

Thomas Evans was a man of the sea and attained worldwide notoriety as a result of claiming to have seen a mermaid “basking on the rocks at Derrygimla, in Errisbeg”. This was reported in the Galway Advertiser in 1819 and later appeared in newspapers around the world.

Three of Thomas Evans’s sons, Thomas, James and Patrick, are named in a lease between Thomas Martin and Thomas Evans, drawn up in 1828 for the demesne and lands at Cleggan. Patrick was present at the banquet for Daniel O’Connell after the repeal meeting in Clifden in 1843, according to the Nation newspaper. He married Deborah Sloper in Clifden Roman Catholic church in 1839. He was relieving officer for Renvyle District during the famine. Nothing is known of the other two.

Thomas Evans had a fourth son, John, who was drowned off Cleggan in 1828, along with his young wife, Ms. O’Donnell from Louisburg. The report in the Newry Telegraph said it was as a result of “the smarting of a plank” on his father’s pleasure boat.

150 years later four O’Sullivan brothers capsized a wooden lakeboat while bringing sheep to an island on Lough Corrib. The prayers they had so diligently lodged, each year on Inchagoill, were repaid with dividends. Only one ewe, that caught her horn in a rib of the boat, was lost. Someone was watching over us that day.

There is evidence that another Evans woman, a Mary Evans, was married to Redmond Joyce, a businessman and Poor Law Guardian in Clifden. Mary was probably Elizabeth’s sister, but, as yet, there is no evidence to prove this. Redmond and Mary’s daughter, Jane, married John O’Sullivan of Cornamona, a brother of my great grandfather Bernard.

I have set out below details of the Joyce and Evans families. I am just missing some little links, but I am hopeful that someone reading this article might provide a little snippet of information that could crack the case.

By Barry O’Sullivan bpos@iol.ie


Elizabeth Evans

Birth About 1820 Cleggan, Co.Galway.

Death 1874 Ashmount, Leenane, Co. Galway.


Thomas Evans (1750-1840) Born Cashel, Co.Tipperary. Buried Ballinakill Cemetery.


Margaret Toole (1799-1839)


Theobald Tobias “Toby” Joyce (1816-1894) son of Big Jack Joyce, Leenane, Co.Galway.

Married 1840 Clifden.


Patrick (1843-1891) married Mary Joyce. Lived in Leagaun, Claddaghduff.

Sarah (1846-1884) married Bernard O’Sullivan, Cloonbrone, Cornamona.

Bridget (1849-1922) married Thomas O’Sullivan, Cloonbrone, Cornamona.

James Bernard (1853-1928) married Barbara Keely. Lived in Market St.,Clifden.

Elizabeth (1856-1940) married John Joyce, Ungwee, Letterfrack.

Honor “Nora” (1857-1920) married John Joyce, Lettershanna, Clifden. Lived in Pittsburgh, Pa.

Thomas Evans (1860-1939) married Margaret Waldron. Lived in Leenane & Abbeyknockmoy.

Margaret (1861-)

Catherine “Emily” (1863-1928) married Michael Coyne, Leenane. Lived in Youngstown, Ohio.

Anne (1864-)

Jane (1866-)
Thomas Evans

Birth About 1750 Cashel Co. Tipperary.

Death 1840 Cleggan, Co. Galway.


Margaret Toole 1799 – 1839.


• Catherine Evans

• James Evans

• Patrick Evans Married Deborah Sloper Clifden in 1839

• Thomas Evans

• John Evans 1807 – 1828. Married Ms. O’Donnell from Louisburg.

• Mary Evans 1817 – Married Redmond Joyce Clifden.

• Elizabeth Evans 1820 – 1874. Married Tobias Joyce Leenane in 1840


  1. I see many great comments on your article. It’s obvious to many readers how talented you are and how well you get your views noticed.

  2. Pat Joyce says:

    My grandfather was thomas Francis joyce who was the youngest son of big jack joyce of muinterowen —–My grand father married Sabina conroy of Rossmuck.
    He must have been a brother of Tobias. My father was John m Joyce who was born in muinterowen in 1907 and was the youngest of 10 children. In 1909 the family moved to Leenane and lived in a house which is now called the Convent .
    Perhaps O HARTS PEDIGREES would be of help to you.

  3. Pat Joyce says:

    it might help you —my father JOHN M Joyce, Muinterowen/ Leenane was related to a Bernard O Sullivan whose family originated from somewhere near cong [ across the Corrib from oughterard]

  4. Barry O'Sullivan says:

    Hello Pat,
    Was your father John M Joyce the wool buyer. If so your grandfather Thomas Francis Joyce was son of Patrick Joyce eldest son of Big Jack Joyce. John M Joyce was my grandfather Bernard O’Sullivan’s 2nd cousin. Bernard lived on the Doorus peninsula Cornamona.
    Barry O’Sullivan

  5. Mellissa Freeman says:

    Has anyone got any information on the Mcdonagh family consisting of Micheal and Catherine and there children Annie,Mary,Rita,shamus,Patrick,john,Thomas and my grandad Joseph Mcdonagh born feb 12 or 14 1935.i would be very grateful.

  6. Maureen Roberts says:

    Good to finally solve the question who was my great-grandfather, Tobias Joyce? He emigrated to Western Australia in 1876 and today I have discovered that his sister Mary Joyce Walsh was on the same ship with her husband and children. I had always believed because of what was on the marriage certificate of Tobias with Eleanor Josephine Brady at North Backflats Western Australia in 1887 that his father was a farmer named John from Roscommon. Tobias and Eleanor had three sons Patrick, Clarence and John who died at age 8 weeks. Clarence was the only one to marry and have children, two sons Denis and Clarence and two daughters Linda who died infancy and Mary. Denis had three children Richard, Robert and Rona. Clarence had five children Maureen, Patrick, Michelle, Kaye and Clarence. Mary had two daughters Shirley and Coral.
    Tobias was given a land grant but I do not know what happened to the land. He worked for the railways for some years then after separating from Eleanor moved to Kalgoorlie. There he was the Watchman for the Towns of Kalgoorlie and Boulder. Tobias was in the news a lot either he was in court as a witness or a defendant. He was at one time a police informant. Tobias claimed to have been in the Irish Constabulary an. d also a Captain the Connaught Rangers with service in the Imperial African Wars ( had the medals to prove it )

  7. Kelly McCarthy says:

    Hi Maureen,
    My 2x great grandmother was Mary Joyce Walsh who firstly immigrated to Fremantle WA then ended up in Adelaide SA. There daughter Mary Walsh married a Edward James McCarthy in SA and they are my great grandparents. Edward and Mary ended up in Esperance WA where there are still a lot of us McCarthy’s. I have been in touch with Barry O’Sullivan and will hopefully meet him in August when my sister and I travel to Ireland.

  8. Barry O'Sullivan says:

    We can now add Mary Joyce Walsh (married to James Walsh of Lee Townland, Maam Valley) and Tobias Joyce to the family of Tobias Joyce & Elizabeth Evans in the article above. Both emigrated to Australia . I am a DNA match with both Maureen Roberts and Kelly McCarthy.
    Barry O’Sullivan

  9. Hi Barry

    Did you find a Kineavy connection in your research? Our Kineavys were from the Island and one married a Julia Joyce. They lived then in Carrowgarriff.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *